How Startups Can Recover From a Down Round

What is a Down Round?

A down round refers to a financing event in which a company raises capital by selling shares at a lower valuation than in the previous funding round. This results in a reduction of the company's valuation compared to the last financing.

In contrast, an up round is when a company raises funds at a higher valuation than before. A flat round occurs when the valuation stays the same between financing events. Down rounds typically happen when a private company misses key business milestones, underperforms growth targets, or faces unfavorable market conditions between funding rounds.

As a result, investors perceive the company to be less valuable than in the past, requiring the company to accept a lower valuation and share price to secure new capital. The existing investors face dilution of their ownership stakes because the company issues more shares at lower prices in a down round. Later investors can gain more equity in the company for less capital compared to earlier investors. For founders and employees holding common stock or options, the share price drop also dilutes the value of their equity. A down round can demotivate the team and be seen as a sign the company is struggling.

Why Do Down Rounds Occur?

‍

Down rounds can happen for a variety of reasons, but most commonly occur when a startup misses key milestones or underperforms compared to projections, market conditions shift, or previous valuations were overly optimistic.

Missed Milestones or Underperformance

A prevalent reason for a down round often occurs when a startup fails to meet milestones outlined in its business plan or falls short of projected growth and revenue targets. Investors rely on the startup's ability to achieve product development, user acquisition, revenue goals and other projections when making funding decisions. Failure to meet these milestones can erode investor trust in the company's worth. This may mean accepting a down round to account for the execution risk.

‍

Market Shifts

The business landscape is always changing, sudden shifts can render a startup's value obsolete. For example, changes in what customers prefer or the emergence of a competitor can significantly affect a company's growth. If market conditions worsen, investors might hesitate to pour money into valuations. This can force startups to accept down rounds to account for the new industry realities.

For example, regulatory changes that benefit incumbents or restrict an emerging business model can hamper a startup's progress. These macro environment shifts can necessitate lower valuations.

Overly Optimistic Previous Valuations

Startups are sometimes overvalued in bull market environments or early funding rounds before properly validating their business models. High-flying unicorns chasing rapid growth at the expense of economics can also command unsustainably high valuations. As subsequent rounds approach, these overvalued startups may find it difficult to justify the same valuations to investors scrutinizing their fundamentals. The startups may then need to take a down round to reset at more reasonable valuations aligned with actual revenues and growth.

Implications for Shareholders

A down round can have significant implications for a startup's shareholders, including founders, employees, and investors. The most direct impact is equity dilution. When a business decides to raise funds through a down round, it offers shares at a reduced value. This results in existing shareholders owning a portion of the company as their shares represent less of the shares available. The level of dilution experienced by shareholders is influenced by the magnitude of the round and how much the valuation has decreased compared to the funding round. Existing investors typically face the largest dilution in a down round.

Beyond dilution, down rounds can also strain relationships with investors. Existing shareholders may feel the company failed to meet expectations and can damage trust. Investors from previous rounds may push for stronger preferences and protections to compensate for the lower valuation. This can cause conflicts over governance rights. Down rounds also risk hurting employee morale. Employees with stock options or equity grants see their potential upside decrease. The lower valuation signals challenges ahead, making retention and hiring more difficult. Employees may doubt leadership's ability to right the ship.

Maintaining strong communication and alignment of interests is critical to preserve relationships. Companies must convince shareholders the down round puts them on better footing going forward. Retaining talent and showing progress post-down round are also key.

Alternatives to a Down Rounds

Rather than accepting a down round and its negative implications, startups do have some alternatives they can consider to raise capital without diluting existing shareholders at a lower valuation. Some options include:

Debt Financing or Convertible Notes

Seeking debt financing or issuing convertible notes can allow a startup to obtain capital without immediately diluting equity. Convertible notes act as debt until conversion into equity at the next qualified financing round, usually with a discount or valuation cap. Debt financing allows startups to borrow capital that gets repaid with interest, without giving up ownership. However, too much debt can be problematic if the startup is unable to repay.

Strategic Partnerships

Forming strategic partnerships with other companies can potentially bring in capital investments and revenue opportunities. An equity investment or commercial partnership with a strategic ally may help the startup continue operations and growth. Partners can also provide technology, resources, distribution channels, industry expertise and other benefits.

Restructuring and Cost-Cutting

Before considering a down round, startups can analyze their business to identify areas for restructuring and cost reductions. This may mean eliminating waste, optimizing operations, reducing headcount, renegotiating supplier and vendor contracts, limiting excess spending, or consolidating overhead costs. Though difficult, restructuring measures can help extend runway and improve capital efficiency.

Avoiding a Down Round

While down rounds are sometimes unavoidable for startups facing challenging circumstances, there are a few key strategies founders can employ to reduce the chances of experiencing a down round:

Set a realistic valuation and fundraising strategy from the outset - Founders should resist the temptation to chase high valuations and instead aim for a valuation that accurately reflects the company's stage, traction, metrics, market landscape, and peer valuations. Padding the valuation excessively in early rounds leaves little room for error in future rounds. Being realistic also helps set proper expectations with investors.

Maintain open communication channels with existing investors - Keep investors updated on progress, milestones, and any hiccups through consistent check-ins. Quickly flag potential misses in targets that may warrant a down round discussion. The more aligned investors are on the company's status, the lower the chances of surprises that can lead to valuation resets.

Build in the flexibility to adapt to changing market conditions - Markets move in cycles and what is feasible in a bull market may not be realistic in a bear market. Founders need to track relevant industry trends and macroeconomic factors, and be ready to make necessary adjustments to valuations or metrics in response to market shifts beyond their control. Signaling this adaptability can give investors more comfort.

Right-size the funding raises at each stage - Raising only the capital necessary to achieve the next set of milestones preserves options for later rounds. Large raises too early often force unrealistic growth and unsustainably high burn rates, increasing the likelihood of missing targets that trigger down rounds. Capital efficiency should be a priority.

Focus on business fundamentals over vanity metrics - Emphasize sound unit economics, clear paths to profitability, and building sustainable competitive advantages versus simply chasing high revenue growth, users or gross merchandise value at all costs. Investors care more about real traction and fundamentals versus vanity metrics that can mask underlying problems.

Investor Perspectives

In instances where a startup opts for a down round, investors need to assess the scenario and make crucial choices regarding their ongoing involvement. While down rounds may lead to discord between founders and investors, there are approaches that investors can employ to establish trust and align motivations during periods. The first factor investors will analyze is why the down round is occurring. If it is due to missed milestones, poor executive decisions, or failure to pivot when necessary, investors may lose confidence in the team's ability to execute. However, external macroeconomic factors, industry shifts, or overly optimistic previous valuations may be reasonable explanations.

Investors will also want to understand the implications of the down round for their ownership stake. With dilution of equity, their potential upside is reduced. Full ratchet anti-dilution provisions from previous rounds can greatly penalize existing shareholders in a down round scenario. Investors need to negotiate appropriate terms to protect against extreme dilution. Changes to liquidation preferences, dividend rights, and other investor rights are likely to occur in a down round. Investors may request increased control or stronger preferences to offset higher risk. However, too many restrictive terms could hinder the company’s progress.

Aligning incentives and maintaining trust with founders is critical. Down rounds force difficult conversations, but transparency and open communication between investors and founders can strengthen relationships. Demonstrating resilience, creating contingency plans, and reaffirming conviction in the core business can help rebuild investor confidence after a down round.

Employee Considerations

Experiencing a down round can greatly affect the employees of a startup. It's crucial to communicate and be transparent to keep morale high and retain individuals during such tough times. When a down round occurs, it is crucial that management informs employees and explains the situation. It's important to communicate the details of the valuation and how it affects employee equity. Management should be honest about the obstacles the company is dealing with while highlighting its strengths and future opportunities.

It's crucial to address any worries employees may have regarding dilution of equity compensation. Existing stock options and grants will decrease in value after a down round. Management can ease some of these concerns by providing refresher or additional grants at the new valuation. Compensating key talent fairly despite the down round is key to retention. Leadership should take steps to motivate and inspire the team during this difficult period. To unite employees, emphasize mission, culture, and values. Engage, reassure, and offer innovative compensation strategies after a down round.

Legal and Regulatory Considerations

‍

Securities Laws Compliance

When issuing new shares at a lower valuation, companies must ensure they comply with relevant securities regulations. In the United States, private companies issuing stock must either register the offering with the SEC or qualify for an exemption such as under Regulation D. Companies must file the proper paperwork, disclosures, and Form D notice when raising a down round. Legal counsel should be engaged to ensure securities law compliance.

Shareholder Approval

Current investors might have to give their consent for the down round funding subject to the company's charter and bylaws. Usually, a majority of voting shareholders must agree to the funding round particularly if it introduces a type of preferred stock. Companies should review requirements and properly notify and obtain approval from current shareholders.

Protecting Stakeholder Interests

Existing shareholders face dilution, so their approval is important. New investor liquidation preferences should not be unfairly senior to existing stakeholders. Companies should be transparent about the impacts and rationale of the down round with all parties. Legal counsel can advise on measures for anti dilution protection like pro rata rights to protect against excessive dilution of specific shareholders.

Post-Down Round Strategy

A down round can feel like a significant blow, but it's important for leadership to regain perspective and focus on the road ahead. The company's core business objectives should remain the guiding priorities. Review the business plan and strategy to identify what's working well versus what may need adjustment in light of new industry or market conditions.

Focus on customers and generating revenue. Deliver value in the marketplace to rebuild momentum. Avoid drastic pivots or overcorrections; stay the course on your core competencies. Demonstrate sound fiscal management and responsibility when utilizing remaining capital.

Reengage with existing investors to restore confidence. Provide transparency into how their funds are being deployed. Highlight milestones achieved and concrete plans to drive growth. Solicit feedback on how to strengthen the business. With improved performance and open communication, investors may support participating in future rounds.

Lay the groundwork for the next funding round. Make introductions to prospective new investors through your networks. Align messaging and materials to address concerns raised in the previous round. Highlight lessons learned and improvements instituted. The down-round experience, while challenging, can demonstrate the team's resilience and ability to course-correct when necessary. With the right preparation, the company can emerge stronger.

‍